How to Report Identity Theft and Recover: A Legal Strategy!

Identity Theft Recovery
13 min read
October 03, 2025

Millions of Americans experience identity theft every year, and most discover pretty quickly that fixing it is not as simple as clicking “reset password.” 

Identity theft isn’t just about stolen credit cards; it can include tax fraud, social security fraud, medical identity theft, and even criminal identity theft (when someone gets arrested under your name).

The effects are devastating. You could find yourself locked out of loans, fighting wrongful debts, or even explaining to potential employers why your background check says you’re a felon in Florida when you’ve never set foot in the state.

Knowing how to report identity theft immediately is critical because the longer it goes unchecked, the worse the fallout.

We lay out a full legal strategy for how to report identity theft and recover from it. We cover every step- from filing police reports to contacting the credit bureaus, the FTC, Social Security, and even banks.

Learn how to dispute false information, how the law protects you, and what to do when know how to report identity theft doesn’t get you the recovery outcome you need.

For more information on identity theft recovery, see our practice page. To get started on recovery now, call today. Consultations are FREE and you pay nothing upfront or out of pocket if we take your case.

How To Report Identity Theft to Police

Law enforcement agencies aren’t always eager to handle financial crimes, but filing a report can be the first crucial step. 

According to countless consumer advocates, victims who skip this step often struggle to get banks or credit bureaus to take their disputes seriously.

How to file an identity theft police report:

  1. Gather evidence: Print fraudulent statements, debt collection letters, or credit reports showing the fake accounts.
  2. Visit your local police department: Many departments will ask you to provide a written affidavit detailing the crime.
  3. Get a copy of the police report: This document will be extremely important when disputing fraudulent accounts with creditors and credit bureaus.

If your local police seem uninterested, insist politely. In many states, including New York and Georgia, departments are legally required to take reports for financial crimes. Without a police report, your dispute letters may not carry as much weight.

How to Report Identity Theft to Credit Bureaus

Credit bureaus – Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion- play a starring role in identity theft fallout.

Once your identity is compromised, fraudulent accounts often appear on your credit report. Knowing how to report identity theft to the credit bureaus quickly can prevent lasting damage.

How to report identity theft to the credit bureaus:

  1. Get free copies of your credit reports from AnnualCreditReport.com and carefully review them for fraudulent activity.
  2. Contact each bureau directly to place a fraud alert.
  3. Send copies of your police report and FTC Identity Theft Report. It’s best to send copies through certified mail to create a document trail.
  4. Request a credit freeze if you’re concerned about more fraudulent accounts.
  5. Contact Consumer Justice Law Firm if the credit bureaus push back – we can make sure they comply with the law.

Why does this matter? Because under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), credit bureaus are legally required to block information that results from identity theft once you provide proper documentation.

If the credit bureaus don’t meet their legal obligations, you may end up Googling “identity theft lawyer near me” to force them into compliance. We’re nationwide, so we’re always near you.

Handcuffs convey that knowing how to report identity theft is important but so is fighting for your rights.

How to Report Identity Theft to the FTC 

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) isn’t a police force, but it’s the central hub for documenting identity theft. Filing with them creates an official record, which is essential for disputes and future lawsuits.

How to file an FTC identity theft report:

Visit Identitytheft.gov. This page will walk you through the process of:

  1. Creating an affidavit documenting the theft.
  2. Generating sample letters to send to creditors and credit bureaus.
  3. Setting up a personalized recovery plan.

This is one of the most important steps in how to report identity theft. Many banks and credit bureaus will demand this document before they consider removing fraudulent charges or accounts.

Keep both digital and physical copies of your FTC report. You’ll be sending this out more than once.

How to Report Identity Theft to Social Security

When your Social Security number is compromised, you’re facing social security fraud, one of the most dangerous forms of identity theft.

Criminals can open new accounts, collect government benefits, or even use it for employment, leaving you with a mess that makes untangling tax fraud look easy.

How to report identity theft to Social Security:

  1. Contact the Social Security Administration directly if you suspect your number is being misused.
  2. File an affidavit with the FTC at IdentityTheft.gov to establish an official record.
  3. Monitor your SSA earnings statement for errors, like jobs you never worked suddenly appearing under your name. 
  4. File IRS Form 14039 if your SSN has been used for tax fraud.
  5. In extreme cases, ask the SSA about a replacement Social Security number (rare, but possible).
  6. Freeze your credit with all three credit bureaus to stop new accounts from being opened in your name.
  7. Contact Consumer Justice Law Firm if government agencies or credit bureaus seem unconcerned, throw up roadblocks, or refuse to act – we’ll make sure your rights are enforced.

If the identity fraud is extensive, you may need to request a new Social Security number. This isn’t easy, but it can be done with sufficient documentation and proof of harm.

And yes, this is exactly the kind of case where an Arizona identity theft lawyer or one in Florida, Georgia, or New York can help navigate the bureaucracy.

How to Report Identity Theft of a Deceased Person 

It sounds unthinkable, but identity thieves often target deceased individuals because there’s less oversight. 

According to consumer fraud experts, this “ghosting” scam costs families millions every year. If a loved one has passed away, knowing how to stop the exploitation and protect their legacy is critical.

How to report identity theft of a deceased person:

  1. File an FTC Identity Theft Report
  • Go to IdentityTheft.gov and file on behalf of the deceased. You may need legal authority such as being the executor or surviving spouse. 
  • If the Social Security number has been misused for taxes, also complete IRS Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit).
  1. Notify the Credit Bureaus
    Contact Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax directly. Send each one a copy of the death certificate and request a “Deceased – Do Not Issue Credit” alert. Ask for a copy of the deceased’s credit report and review it for fraudulent accounts.
  2. Notify the IRS and Social Security Administration
  • Send the death certificate to the IRS office where the deceased normally filed taxes. 
  • Notify the Social Security Administration by phone or in person so that benefits can’t be stolen.
  1. Inform Financial Institutions
  • Contact all banks, credit card companies, lenders, and insurance providers. 
  • Close any unnecessary accounts and mark active ones as “Closed Account Holder Deceased.”
  1. File a Police Report (if fraud has already occurred)
  • Bring the death certificate, your FTC report, and any evidence of fraudulent activity to your local police department. 
  • Request a copy of the police report to use later in disputes with creditors.
  1. Take Other Protective Steps
  • Cancel digital assets such as email, social media, and other online accounts. 
  • Notify the Department of Motor Vehicles to cancel the deceased’s driver’s license. 
  • Report suspected online scams to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov
  • Remove the deceased from mailing lists through the Data & Marketing Association to prevent thieves from intercepting pre-approved credit offers.
  1. Contact Consumer Justice Law Firm
    If credit bureaus, banks, or government agencies fail to act, contact us. We’ll step in to enforce your rights and protect your loved one’s legacy.

Failing to act quickly can result in fraudulent accounts being opened in your loved one’s name, which can create legal and financial headaches for surviving family members.

How to Dispute Identity Theft On Credit Reports

Once fraudulent accounts hit your credit report, you must act fast. Here’s the legal playbook for how to report identity theft in this context:

  1. Get Your Credit Reports
    Request free copies from AnnualCreditReport.com. Pull all three (Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax) so you don’t miss anything.
  2. Review Line by Line
    Examine every account, balance, and inquiry. Flag anything you don’t recognize, including small charges or unfamiliar lenders.
  3. File Written Disputes with Each Bureau
    Send your disputes in writing, by certified mail with return receipt to Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax. Clearly identify each fraudulent account or entry.
  4. Include Documentation
    Attach your police report, FTC Identity Theft Report, and any supporting evidence such as letters from creditors or billing statements.
  5. Assert Your Legal Rights
    Reference the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). This law requires credit bureaus to investigate your dispute and remove inaccurate information within 30 days.
  6. Keep Proof of Mailing
    Save copies of your letters, reports, and USPS certified mail receipts. This paper trail is vital if you need to escalate legally.
  7. Contact Consumer Justice Law Firm
    If credit bureaus ignore your dispute, delay, or refuse to correct fraudulent entries, we’ll take action to enforce your rights under the FCRA.

The law requires credit bureaus to investigate disputes within 30 days. If they fail to remove fraudulent accounts, you may have grounds for legal action. This is where having an identity theft lawyer can turn the tide.

How To Dispute Identity Theft With Banks

According to the Fair Credit Billing Act (FCBA) and the Electronic Funds Transfer Act, consumers have strong legal protections against fraudulent charges. The catch? You must report them quickly.

How to report identity theft to banks and dispute it:

  1. Notify Your Bank Immediately
    Call as soon as you see fraudulent charges. Time is critical – report within 2 business days for debit card fraud to get maximum protections.
  2. Put Your Dispute in Writing
    Even after you talk to them on the phone, send a written dispute letter by certified mail, return receipt requested, citing your rights under the FCBA (for credit cards) or EFTA (for debit/ATM/ACH). Note the phone call in your letter. Keep copies of everything.
  3. Request Chargebacks or Reversals
    Ask the bank to reverse unauthorized charges or transactions.
  4. Demand Written Confirmation
    Banks are legally required to acknowledge your dispute in writing, usually within 30 days.
  5. Close and Replace Compromised Accounts
    Request new account numbers, debit/credit cards, and online login credentials so fraudsters can’t hit the same accounts again.
  6. Keep Proof of Mailing and Records
    Save copies of your dispute letters, account statements, and USPS receipts.
  7. Contact Consumer Justice Law Firm
    If your bank stalls, refuses to reverse charges, or blames you for fraud, we’ll enforce your rights under FCBA and EFTA.

Banks are supposed to protect you, but they often resist refunds without mountains of paperwork. Having a police report and FTC identity theft report in hand strengthens your claim. If the bank drags its feet, a lawyer can escalate under federal law. 

Keep copies of every communication with your bank. Emails, letters, and even phone logs can become evidence if the case goes legal.

At some point, DIY fixes stop working and you have to stop questioning how to report identity theft and start looking at how to get professional help instead.

You’ve filed with the police, the credit bureaus, the FTC, and even Social Security, but fraudulent accounts keep reappearing. Or worse, debt collectors are still calling to demand payment on debts you never created.

This is your signal that it’s time to hire an identity theft lawyer.  

The right lawyer can:

  1. File lawsuits under the FCRA, FCBA, EFTA, and FDCPA.
  2. Force banks, credit bureaus, or debt collectors to remove fraudulent accounts.
  3. Pursue damages for financial and emotional distress.
  4. Guide you through recovering benefits if Social Security fraud is involved.
  5. Stop harassing collection calls by demanding all communication go through your lawyer.
  6. Obtain court orders requiring immediate corrections to your credit reports.
  7. Represent you at no upfront cost, since consumer protection laws allow attorneys to recover their fees from the wrongdoers.

Whether you’re searching for an identity theft lawyer near me in New York, Florida, Georgia, Arizona, or some place else – the key is finding someone experienced in consumer protection law.

Contact Consumer Justice Law Firm for a free case review. If you’ve just discovered identity theft, we’ll walk you through the entire identity theft recovery process. If you’ve been battling it for awhile, we’ll take over the fight and make sure your rights are enforced.

GET JUSTICE! Fight to Fix Errors & Get Money

At Consumer Justice Law Firm, we know that figuring out how to report identity theft is just the beginning. Real recovery requires persistence, strategy, and often, legal firepower.

With over 75 years of combined experience, our team has fought, and won against banks, credit bureaus, and debt collectors who refused to take responsibility in the aftermath of identity theft.

We can help from the first minute you discover identity theft until you finally sigh a breath of relief when it’s all over. We don’t just help you file disputes; we build full legal strategies to restore your financial reputation.

Whether you’re dealing with identity fraud, social security fraud, or stubborn credit reporting agencies, we use the law to hold them accountable.

If you’re ready to stop researching how to report identity theft and just start fighting back, call Consumer Justice Law Firm today.

FREE Consultations! We only get paid when we win, and the companies we sue pay our legal bills. No Justice, No Fee.TM